In conversations with newly certified NFL agents, I’ve sensed a greater sense of urgency this year than in previous years. Shoot, it’s been present even as I’ve spoken to more seasoned contract advisors. The dilemma is this: legitimate (and sometimes, not-so-legitimate) NFL prospects are harder than ever to recruit.
I have a few theories why this year has been such a challenge.
The new 5-for-5 rule means more players are going to stick around and cash in. One agent I spoke to said he recently had his November discussion with an NFL scout, during which he normally gets 25-30 sleepers, players who are off the grid but possible draft picks. This year, that conversation produced fewer than 10 leads. Basically, every player has a “Covid bonus year” coming to him.
More players than ever already have NIL representation. To some degree, the 2027 draft class is already “locked.” The message I get back from contract advisors these days is that they spend more time on retention than they do on recruiting. Players automatically think their agents will just ride with them into the next level. College GMs tell me even the walk-ons have representation. This is complicated by the fact that a lot of players don’t understand that their NIL agent can’t necessarily rep them on the next level. Unless you are NFLPA-certified, you can’t negotiate a player’s deal. Maybe some agents are willing to offer this service (on a non-official basis) for free, but most people like to get paid for their work. What’s more, NIL agents are far less likely to have a network of NFL contacts, and you need that if you’re a UDFA-level prospect. I’ve seen some set up a “succession plan” with an NFLPA-licensed friend, but not all of them do it.
These are the main two. But there are other reasons:
Players are taking a dimmer view of NFL agents: Now that the vast majority of legit NFL prospects have a pile of NIL cash, the urgency to find an agent to cover training costs has lessened. Like it or not — and, for the record, I do not subscribe to this — a lot of players see this as an agent’s sole (or, at least, most important) role.
Players are solicited 24-7-365 instead of (mainly) their senior seasons. When every time you go to Instagram someone you don’t know is urging you to “check DMs,” after a while, you don’t do it. I’ve seen lots of examples of NIL agents soliciting players by promising some kind of big-bucks marketing deal. I’d love to know how many actually have anything.
A lot of agents are cutting fees and offering benefits to sign. Don’t call these “inducements,” per se, because NFLPA contract advisors have been doing such things since time immemorial; the Players Association looks the other way because it’s a net positive for players. Anyway, I’ve heard it’s not uncommon for agents to walk their fees down from 5 percent to 4, 3 and even 1 percent. They are also starting to throw in other benefits (like paid offseason training). It’s a death spiral for the business, but that’s where the market is going. If you’re a new agent willing to cover training, maybe this is a plus, but it’s just one more thing that’s going to punch you in the wallet.