• About

Succeed in Football

~ The daily blog written by ITL's Neil Stratton

Succeed in Football

Author Archives: itlneil

Saluting Franks And A Bowl Success Story

10 Thursday Sep 2015

Posted by itlneil in Agents, Scouts

≈ Leave a comment

Tags

Andrew Franks, National Bowl

If you read Succeed in Football regularly, you know I’m a big fan of Michael Quartey, a guy who’s done a lot of things in football (agent, coach, college player) before finally finding his niche running two small all-star games, the FCS and National Bowls, in South Florida.

These games were once scorned as irrelevant evaluation tools strictly for indoor football teams, but that is changing. One reason for that change is new Dolphins starting kicker Andrew Franks, who came to South Florida by way of Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute in Troy, NY. His performance in the practices leading up to the National Bowl, as well as his play in the game, got him noticed by the hometown Dolphins, who brought him in as an undrafted free agent. Here’s a little more about Franks post-National Bowl, and how he climbed the draft ranks on the way to kicking Sunday for the Fins.

In a way, both Franks and Quartey are fighting their way toward a bigger reputation. The National Bowl had 11 NFL teams present this year, many with more than one scout, and five more CFL teams. That’s up from eight NFL teams in 2013.

I asked Michael about Franks and how he wandered into the path of first the National Bowl, then the NFL. Here are a few takeaways from our conversation.

  • Franks is the first National Bowl alumnus ever to kick off the season as an NFL starter. “We’ve had a couple guys start the season on practice squads, then get activated mid-season,” Quartey said, “but this is the first time we’ve had an opening-week starter.”
  • Franks was nominated by his coach and another key influencer: his aunt. They both reached out to game organizers on Twitter. “We took a look and saw that he had some level of ability,” Quartey said. “His coach told us that some NFL teams were interested, which was a good thing to hear with a DIII kid.”
  • Perhaps because he had come from a DIII school, Franks was pretty open to coming to the game. Unlike most games, the National Bowl requires a fee to participate ($595 plus the cost of travel). “His family was pretty aggressive on wanting him to come to the game,” Quartey said. “For a small-school guy, there’s just not a lot of opportunities for events with NFL and CFL scouts, and it was a pleasant surprise that he wanted to come.”
  • Since it’s a hometown game, the Dolphins have been big proponents of the National Bowl and its sister game, the FCS Bowl, both run by Quartey. “The Dolphins were one of the first teams to commit to us since we moved to FIU (in December 2013), and they have had 3-4 scouts there from the beginning to now, so they definitely showed us love. They . . .took a look at him, and saw that he had a strong leg, and a bunch of scouts were interested in him.”
  • Even after an impressive week at the National Bowl, Quartey was surprised to see Franks win the Dolphins’ job. “Some guys excel and then get that opportunity,” Quartey said, “but you never know once they get to the NFL how they’re going to compete for that roster spot.”

WSW: Who Does The Best Job of Drafting?

09 Wednesday Sep 2015

Posted by itlneil in Scouts

≈ Leave a comment

Tags

NFL Scouting

One thing that intrigues me (and a lot of people) is the scouting process, and how NFL teams evaluate players. Is there one team that seems to do a better job than others, and that most NFL teams recognize as superior in the draft process?

In Fall 2014, during a presentation for sport management majors at Rice University, I asked former Texans, Redskins and Lions scout Miller McCalmon if there was one team known around the league as the best at finding college talent. If you’d rather watch him respond than read his response, click here.

“Without question, the Green Bay Packers probably do as good a job as anybody in the league. Somebody did a statistical analysis, and they listed the amount of players, I think at the start of the year (in 2014) that were drafted players. Green Bay had the most percentage of drafted players of any other team in the league. I would think Baltimore would be up there pretty high, too; they do a good job of drafting.

“It was interesting. Along with my duties as a pro scout in Detroit, I did the advanced scouting, so I never watched us play. I was always at our next opponent’s game. I had to write a report, and I’d get that prepared during the week, then after the game I would finish it up and send it to the intern, and he would run it off and hand it to the coaches so they’d have my report from the game. But we would have a section in there of the free agent signings and that sort of thing. A couple of years, Green Bay didn’t have any. Most teams would have four or five guys that they signed as free agents; well, Green Bay wouldn’t have any at times. Now, later on in the season, it would be more because they’d have to pick up somebody because of injuries or that sort of thing. But I think statistically, if you go down and you look at their roster, they have more drafted players on their roster than probably any other team, and I’d be surprised if there was anybody that didn’t have that.”

Three Things to Watch for in The Agent: Ep 5

08 Tuesday Sep 2015

Posted by itlneil in Scouts

≈ Leave a comment

Tags

NFL Scouting

If you’re an aspiring football professional, tonight’s a great place for insights into the business side of the game. Here are three things to watch for in Episode 5 of The Agent (10E/9C, Esquire Network):

  • The show opens in St. Petersburg, Fla., where the Shrine Game is played. You’ll notice that the field where practices are held is ringed by scouts, coaches, agents, financial planners and others who work in the game. What you probably can’t tell is that the group is very loosely regulated. Almost anyone can walk in there, and as long as they don’t make a spectacle of themselves, have pretty much unfettered access to hundreds of potential NFL employers. I’ve always wondered why more eager young job-seekers don’t take advantage of these games. Not a year goes by that I don’t see dozens of young people hoping to work in football at the combine, because it gets all the press, but rarely at all-star games. Access is way better at all-star games than it is at the combine, which is like a party for invitees only. If you want to win a job in football, you’re going to have to irritate a whole lot of people before you get that one champion who’s willing to take a risk on you. There’s no better place to ‘irritate’ lots of people in one setting than at these games.
  • Speaking of jobs, there are three elite training facilities portrayed in tonight’s episode. They are the Pensacola, Fla., location of Exos; Miami-based Bommarito Performance Systems; and Weston, Fla.-based Fit Speed. All are excellent, and all are pretty work-intensive. I’m always hearing from young people who want to find a profession in football, and the default job is always scout or agent. Why not consider the combine prep business? It requires lots of people and has several facets to it, and is still taking shape, with lots of permutations and new applications. A young person who volunteered with a top combine prep facility could very quickly learn the business, identify trends, and quickly make himself very useful/valuable to key people. In fact, I bet one could make the contacts to do almost anything in the business from a combine prep service. Lots of paths cross in the training field, and there are dozens of good training programs that work with players all over the country.
  • One more thing to notice: this week’s show takes place in the January/February time frame, two key months in the draft process. Almost the whole show is shot at an all-star game and training facilities, all in Florida. If you are looking for NFL opportunities, you have to go where the football business is, and the Sunshine State is essential to the draft process, for various reasons. If you’re already in the state, you’re in great position to succeed. If you’re not, but you have easy access to the state, take advantage of that. Florida is not only one of the top 2-3 states for football talent, but it’s also got a warm-weather climate that really helps in the months leading up to the draft.

Enjoy the show, and don’t forget to join in during our live-tweet tonight. I’ve got four pages of notes to churn out tonight during the broadcast. Don’t miss it!

A Message to Aspiring NFL Players

07 Monday Sep 2015

Posted by itlneil in Agents

≈ 1 Comment

Tags

NFL agent

Today, I got contacted through Twitter by a player who hoped to be on a 53-man roster this week. We met because he played in one of the all-star games during the ’15 draft cycle, and we’ve become friendly since. I like him and was glad to hear from him. Anyway, he asked me a few tips about finding a new agent.

This is a pretty regular occurrence, and this won’t be the last message I get this week from players frustrated with their circumstances. It’s even possible that this young man’s agent did a lousy job, but I think there are a few things that need to be said when this situation arises.

  • Players aren’t rejected by the NFL because they had a bad agent. Obviously, there’s no way and no how an NFL team was going to overlook the players drafted in the first round last spring, no matter how bad their representation.
  • Most of the time, players get extra chances because they had an agent. Agents get players into all-star games; call teams in March, begging scouts to attend out-of-the-way pro days; beg teams again after the draft, hoping to get their players undrafted free agent deals; and often call all summer, begging teams to take one more look.
  • If your agent didn’t do a lot of begging, it doesn’t necessarily mean he’s not a good agent. It just might mean that he came to the conclusion you’re not NFL timber. That doesn’t make you a bad player, or a bad person. It just means you’re not in the top 1 percent of the top 1 percent of football players.
  • If you’re frustrated because you’re not in the league, think about how frustrated he is. No. 1, there’s an excellent chance he came out of pocket for thousands of dollars to get you ready for this day. No. 2, he thought you could play or he wouldn’t have signed you, and he’s been proven wrong. No. 3, it’s really frustrating to be told, time after time, that the team is “full,” or just getting no call back at all, or plainly told “don’t call back.” All of these are regular responses from agents calling, hoping for a chance for a client. It’s pretty soul-crushing.
  • Contrary to popular belief, the CFL is not automatic if you don’t play in the NFL. Shoot, even the Arena League isn’t automatic. You need slightly different skill sets for each of those leagues. Sometimes — very rarely — a player lacks the skill sets for those leagues, but is a better fit for the NFL.
  • The NFL just came off its most intensive period of player evaluation. Making cuts from 90 to 75 isn’t easy, and making cuts from 75 to 53 can be positively painful. There will be many players cut this weekend that wind up having two- to three-year NFL careers, either active or on the practice squad. The point is, those players cut this weekend are pretty much the next call for a team with injuries. If you didn’t spend the last six weeks in camp — and I don’t mean this in a bad way — you probably aren’t getting an NFL job.

If this post spoke to you, and is pretty accurate to your situation, I don’t want you to be discouraged or give up. I only want you to understand the odds against you. That’s the only reason I write this. I want everyone to succeed in football; shoot, that’s our motto. But not everyone can, and that doesn’t make you a bad person.

WSW: Five Facts About Larry Donnell

03 Thursday Sep 2015

Posted by itlneil in Agents, Scouts

≈ Leave a comment

Tags

Larry Donnell, NFL agent, NFL Scouting

One of the best things about sports in general (and football, especially) is that it’s full of good stories. Today, let’s talk about Giants TE Larry Donnell, a player was almost completely unknown until he burst onto the scene with three TD catches in New York’s win over the Redskins last year in a Thursday night game.

The full story of Donnell’s ascension from lightly used tight end at Grambling to one of Eli Manning’s favorite targets is beyond the scope of today’s post, and the New York Post has already done a good job with that here.

I just want to point out a few of the interesting aspects of his story that didn’t make it into the Post’s story.

  • He was fired by his first agent: His current agent, Tamika Cheatham of 413 Sports in Glendale, Ariz., only signed him after Donnell’s trainer called her, begging her to take him, in the Spring of 2011. She only knew the trainer because she had worked with him before on another long shot player. “The interesting thing is that after the Redskins game, that agent was trying his darnedest to get him back,” Tamika said.
  • He tried out for the Arena League, CFL and even the defunct UFL: “I didn’t even meet him until after he went to the NFL Super Regional, and I brought him out here to do a workout for the (AFL’s Arizona) Rattlers and that’s when I met him, and the Rattlers thought he was too green.”
  • The Giants originally contacted him via email: Due to the lockout, NFL teams didn’t sign undrafted free agents in 2011. That meant they couldn’t reach out to him until July when the lockout ended. By then, Donnell had changed phone numbers from when he was workout out for teams in March, but someone in the Giants’ front office found an email address that still worked.
  • Despite his inspiring story, he’s not a budding Michael Strahan: “When he first had that game, for the first week or so, he was on every news and radio show, and he is definitely ‘afraid’ of everything outside the locker room. I’ve offered to get him media training, but Larry was like, ‘no, I just can’t do it yet.’ He’s really, really low key.”
  • Tamika helped him keep focused during his two-year pre-Giants odyssey: “I met another young man (a previous client) who had a chance with Tampa Bay, and that fell apart because he didn’t have the work ethic, so I rode Larry pretty hard.”

 

Three Things to Watch for in Tonight’s ‘The Agent’

01 Tuesday Sep 2015

Posted by itlneil in Agents

≈ Leave a comment

Tags

NFL agent

I hope you’ll be tuning in tonight at 10E/9C for Episode 4 of ‘The Agent’ on the Esquire Network. I know everyone in the business that I’ve spoken to in the business will be catching it, or at least the replay afterwards. Here are three things to focus on as you watch.

  • Ed Wasielewski spends a lot of time trying to convince an unsigned NFL veteran to think of himself as a fullback, rather than a tight end. Ed has to cajole, plead, beg and persuade the player (and his fiance’!) to consider a position switch because it’s the only way he’s getting another NFL tryout. Probably 10-12 minutes of the show is spent with Ed on the phone with him, taking him to dinner, or otherwise communicating his need to accept his new fate. It’s incredible for a person outside the game to see this, but players get stuck, mentally, and forget that they are perhaps not as special and deserving of special treatment as they think they are. It usually takes a player 2-3 years outside the game to see how unique it is to be a pro football player.
  • Peter Schaffer brings in Mike Murphy, a former Dolphins scout, to provide interview training for his clients. They cover a number of things, but I thought the most striking part of the show is when Murphy is asking tough, direct questions to the players. While agents (like Ed with his client) have to be very schmoozy when trying to persuade their clients, NFL types don’t have to kiss up to them at all. This is something else players don’t easily accept. As an agent, you have to prepare them for this paradigm shift. It’s not always an easy transition, which is one reason Peter does this. Interview training has become a pretty standard part of combine prep, and this is one reason why.
  • The trainer featured in tonight’s show is Orlando-based Tom Shaw of Tom Shaw Sports. Tom has worked with hundreds of first-round picks and has decades in the game. But the funny thing is, almost every time you see him tonight, he has on Patriots gear (he works with the Pats during training camp every year). I work with people who are trying to break into the game all the time, and they may want to offer combine prep, or interview training, or any number of other services. But if they don’t have some kind of league background or at least a peripheral tie to the NFL, I always let them know they have an uphill battle ahead. There’s no substitute for the NFL brand when it comes to draft prospects seeking credibility from their trainers, handlers, advisors, etc.

10 Questions That Might Indicate You Won’t Be Drafted

31 Monday Aug 2015

Posted by itlneil in Scouts

≈ Leave a comment

Tags

NFL Scouting

A week ago, I discussed 10 questions that an aspiring NFL player might ask himself that could give him a better idea of if he’d be drafted by the NFL. It was pretty well-received, so this week, I thought I’d look at the other side of the coin.

As always, the disclaimer — you can’t determine whether or not a player will be drafted or not drafted on paper. This is just a guide, a series of questions that might be indicators. Nothing more.

Here  goes.

  • Did your school hold a ‘junior day?’
  • Did you play below the FBS level?
  • Were you a regular starter for your team less than one full season?
  • Do you play offensive guard, center, inside linebacker, fullback, punter or kicker?
  • Did you change positions immediately before your senior year?
  • Have you ever been arrested for any offenses related to sexual or domestic assault?
  • Are you more than 20 percent below the average NFL height, weight or speed for your position?
  • Did you suffer a season-ending injury as a senior?
  • Did you experience more than one surgery to any one organ/joint/muscular group during your college career?
  • Did you play for a college west of the Mississippi?

The first two questions are related. Most FBS schools do hold junior days, whereas most small schools do not. What’s a junior day? Briefly, it’s the day in the spring (usually March or April) that the two big scouting combines come through and collect height, weight and 40 time for as many rising seniors as possible. Also, no more than 15-20 players from non-FBS schools get drafted each year, and usually late. That’s less than 10 percent.

Question 3 is pretty common sense. Question 4 is also pretty straightforward — these are the non-sexy positions most teams see as a commodity.

Question 5 is a bit of a feast-or-famine question. Many teams actually find good athletes at new positions as very enticing, so it’s possible this could be a benefit. But more often, it’s a negative.

Question 6 is a little tricky. Players get arrested all the time, but all such offenses are not created equal. Any kind of sexual offense is a big no-no, and obviously, we’re in an era where teams are not at all forgiving when it comes to domestic assaults. It’s important to note, however, that if a player is supremely talented, some team will roll the dice.

Question 7 is a basic are-you-right-physically-for-the-league question.

Question 8 is not hard and fast, but usually, teams want to be absolutely sure a player is healthy when he comes to camp so they can properly evaluate him. If not, he’s damaged goods and no-go. Question 9 is also health-related, and usually this area is cleared up during ‘medical day’ at the combine.

Question 10 is an illustration of the fact that all teams do not visit all schools equally. Remote schools, especially smaller and less successful ones, don’t get the same exposure.

As always, these are not in any way the final measure for players hoping to make it to the league. Still, I feel it’s a pretty good overview of the negatives that are foremost in the minds of most scouts.

Why So Much Ed on ‘The Agent?’

27 Thursday Aug 2015

Posted by itlneil in Agents

≈ Leave a comment

Tags

NFL agent

Since the Esquire Network series ‘The Agent’ kicked off three-plus weeks ago, I’ve been talking about it quite a bit with other agents, financial planners and other people in the game. Here’s one response I get from them frequently: “Why do they did they film Ed Wasielewski so much?”

That’s a valid question. Ed has not only gotten lots of film time, but he’s also live-tweeted the show and held an AMA (Ask Me Anything) on Reddit on Tuesday. Meanwhile, Jeff Guerriero of Pro Source Sports didn’t even show up on Episode 2, and the real insider-level recruiting video has almost always centered on Ed and his potential clients.

There are a couple reasons for this. No. 1, this show is Ed’s baby. When the show was originally being pitched, it was Ed and seasoned NFL producer Amani Martin doing the pitching. The show was even called, ‘Agent Ed.’ It wasn’t until the Esquire Network expressed an interest that another three agents were screened and added to the show.

No. 2, Ed has put the most blood on the screen, so to speak, of all four agents, and it’s not really close. Here’s something I learned recently. The producers of the show sent high-def, state-of-the-art cameras to each of the four contract advisors to film themselves around the office. Others filmed their kids, or day-to-day business interactions, or other mundane activities. Ed used his to film his final interaction with Connecticut DC Byron Jones as Jones tells him it’s not going to work out, and he’s going with New York City-based SportStars. That’s not the kind of thing most agents want to see on film, but Ed was willing to put himself out there.

The feedback I’ve gotten from most agents has been that they really like Ed, but almost wince when they see him go into a final meeting with a player, knowing it’s not going to turn out well (as with Indiana RB Tevin Coleman and his family). They’re constantly astounded by his willingness to look vulnerable and face rejection on camera. But ultimately, they all praise the show’s authenticity. Each one of them says he’s been in the situations that Ed faces, and that’s why I think the show is a must for anyone who aspires to work in the game.

I’ve also talked to several agents who were approached about doing the show, but didn’t want to take the risks that Ed is taking. It’s still to be determined what impact the show will have on Ed’s practice, and I admire his courage.

If you haven’t given the show a chance yet because you’re busy with ‘Hard Knocks’ or some other show, I encourage you to give it a try. It certainly has captured an audience with people in the game.

WSW: A Peek Inside Pre-Combine Interview Training

26 Wednesday Aug 2015

Posted by itlneil in Agents, Scouts

≈ Leave a comment

Tags

NFL agent, NFL Scouting

 Peter Schaffer w-clients in Fla

Today, for WSW, I thought I’d tell the back story associated with something you’ll see next Tuesday on ‘The Agent,’ and that you saw a glimpse of in the tease at the end of the show.

Next week, Episode 4 showcases Peter Schaffer of Authentic Athletix as he brings in former Dolphins scout Mike Murphy to put three prospects through interview training. He sits down with Florida State DE Mario Edwards Jr. (2/35, Raiders), Louisville SS Gerod Holliman (7/239, Steelers) and Syracuse OB Dyshawn Davis (UDFA, Steelers), asking them the tough questions they’re likely to hear from scouts. Questions about disciplinary situations and arrests, drug use, injuries and other ‘negatives’ that might be part of each of their background.

This is a common practice; more and more, ex-scouts are hired by agents to help their clients become more comfortable during the scouting process. At ITL, we help connect agents to former scouts all the time.

At any rate, you’ll see a lot more than just three players sitting at the table with Mike. You’ll actually see quite a few older gentlemen sitting there (as you see in the picture above), and there’s a reason for that.

At 53, Peter remains a competitive lacrosse player, and annually plays in a major national tournament for players 40 and over. The tournament, held in Florida over Martin Luther King weekend, falls on the days when the Shrine Game is played (Saturday) and the Sunday before players arrive in Mobile, Ala., for the Shrine Game. It’s a brief break during a busy time.

Every year, for the tournament, Peter rents a house in Ft. Lauderdale, where several of the lacrosse players bunk for the weekend, as well as his draft clients. Many of his lacrosse teammates are graduates of Ivy League and other esteemed schools (Cornell, Franklin & Marshall, Brown and other schools). Another teammate, Anthony Katagas, is now a major Hollywood producer (he won an Academy Award for ’12 Years a Slave’).

Last year, to create an interesting scenario for ‘The Agent,’ Peter decided to conduct an experiment. He pits his lacrosse buddies, most of them doctors, lawyers and captains of industry, against his players as they take the Wunderlich, the basic intelligence test for the football industry. It’s almost like a 12-minute SAT exam.

Peter hinted that he created distractions during the test, aside from the cameras chronicling every move at the table. He also said his teammates’ scores, as compared to those of his clients, were pretty comparable.

It will be interesting to see what develops. We’ll have to wait until Tuesday to find out. I hope you’ll check it out.

Three Things To Look For in ‘The Agent’ Tonight

25 Tuesday Aug 2015

Posted by itlneil in Agents

≈ 1 Comment

Tags

NFL agent

Tonight, Episode 3 of ‘The Agent’ starts at 10E/9C. Here are a few things to look for.

  • Sunny Shah’s firm, 320 Sports, is bought out: Each week in the intro, we get to hear that Shah had back-to-back Top 15 picks, and that’s obviously real success (though in fairness, one of those picks fired him shortly after the draft). Hearing this, one might think, why would he want to merge? The answer is simple. The business is incredibly volatile, and agents are always on a boom-or-bust cycle. Though you could hit it big one year, there are absolutely no guarantees that success will carry over. A regular salary, health insurance, and a 401(k) are not in the picture when you launch your agency. Shah sees a window to a ‘normal’ life and takes it.
  • Indiana’s Tevin Coleman picks an agent: Last week, we saw Ed Wasielewski deal with the disappointment of losing out on Connecticut’s Byron Jones, who went on to be the first-round selection of the Cowboys. This week, we are taken into the conference room where Team Coleman conducts its final interviews, and we find out if Ed’s multiple cross-country trips bear fruit. During the first episode, I noted that the Colemans conducted their final interviews in a unique way. I’ll illustrate and expand on that tonight during my live-tweet.
  • Pro Source signs two players: Jeff Guerriero’s firm didn’t make so much as a cameo in last week’s show, but this week, they have a pretty prominent role. An impact defensive lineman (Kentucky DT Za’Darius Smith) and a long shot cornerback (Grambling’s Tyree Hollins) sign on the dotted line, and we get to see what’s next as they line up residences, begin training, etc. One thing I think this illustrates is the regional nature of recruiting for most firms. So far, we’ve seen Guerriero and Co. sign a player from Alabama (Smith) and Louisiana (Hollins) and recruit a player from the agency’s hometown (Mississippi State’s Dillon Day). Presuming you have the licenses and the resources, there are no restrictions on where you recruit, but the expenses of casting a wide net usually preclude most agencies from traveling too far.

If you’re interested in the business of football and how decisions are shaped off the field, I hope you’ll tune in tonight. While you’re watching, I hope you’ll check out our live tweet. We’ll be sending out 50-60 bits of information and analysis during tonight’s broadcast. See you tonight!

← Older posts
Newer posts →

Archives

Inside the League

Inside the League

Create a free website or blog at WordPress.com.

Privacy & Cookies: This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you agree to their use.
To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: Cookie Policy
  • Subscribe Subscribed
    • Succeed in Football
    • Join 90 other subscribers
    • Already have a WordPress.com account? Log in now.
    • Succeed in Football
    • Subscribe Subscribed
    • Sign up
    • Log in
    • Report this content
    • View site in Reader
    • Manage subscriptions
    • Collapse this bar

Loading Comments...